Programmatic Perspectives publishes articles related to programmatic issues related to technical communication. ISSN 2326-1412
Volume 8 Issue 2 (Fall 2016)
Lee-Ann Kastman Breuch, University of Minnesota
Victoria Sadler, Metropolitan State University
This issue preview welcomes the community to Programmatic Perspectives, and it considers the theme of programmatic research.
Programmatic Research in Technical Communication: An Interpretive Framework for Writing Program Assessment
Nancy W. Coppola, New Jersey Institute of Technology
Norbert Elliot, New Jersey Institute of Technology
Faye Newsham, Scope Infotech, Inc.
Postscript by Andrew Klobucar, New Jersey Institute of Technology
Abstract. Important advances have been demonstrated in the assessment of writing programs. In this paper, we identify an application of programmatic research based on an accountability framework for writing program assessment. A form of relational modeling that allows a postsecondary institution to identify and fashion the variables that impact the writing program, the application is termed Design for Assessment (DFA). To demonstrate its benefits, we review contemporary views of program assessment, explicate the interpretative features of the framework, and describe a case study application. We close with heuristic questions for program assessment attentive to stakeholder contributions. A postscript from the current program director at our institution provides a reflective statement on the need for evidence-based responsiveness in writing program design.
Keywords. pDesign for Assessment (DFA); empirical methods; program assessment; technical, scientific, and professional communication; variable modeling
Connecting Programmatic Research with Social Media: Using Data from Twitter to Inform Programmatic Decisions
Chris Lam, University of North Texas
Mark Hannah, University of Arizona
Erin Friess, University of North Texas
Abstract. Traditional data sources provide technical communication programs with a variety of useful decision-making metrics. However, many of these data sources are constrained by a variety of factors such as misalignment of institutional and programmatic goals and the summative nature of programmatic data and its subsequent application. Therefore, we argue for the use of data from Twitter to inform decisions about curriculum, assessment, and long-term programmatic vision. In this article, we outline relevant research questions related to programmatic decision making and then describe how to collect, analyze, and apply Twitter data to answer those questions.
Keywords. social media, Twitter, curriculum, assessment, data analysis
Disempowered Minority Students: The Struggle for Power and Position in a Graduate Professional Writing Program
Susan Popham, Indiana University Southeast
Abstract. To meet the complex realities of our contemporary society, academic programs in technical writing should examine diligently the current lack of African-American participation and explore possible ways in which programs may be marketed, revised, and shaped to meet the expectations and needs of potential African-American students. This study used individual interviews with five African-American women while they were pursuing graduate degrees (MA and PhD) in a professional writing program. With a theoretical framework of positionality and agency theory, this article describes with detail how these women faced complex challenges: choosing such a degree program, learning needed academic and career skills, negotiating invisible racial difficulties, and creating support systems for themselves. The article concludes with suggestions for creating programs that may be more amenable to the challenges faced by minority graduate students, like the women in this study.
Keywords. African-American women, minority graduate students, position, agency, power, powerlessness.
Strategic Assessment and Usability Studies: Tracing the Evolution of Identity and Community Engagement in an Undergraduate Professional and Technical Writing Program
Scott J. Kowalewski, Saginaw Valley State University
Bill Williamson, Saginaw Valley State University
Abstract. In this article, we reflect on ongoing, annual assessments at our institution: Saginaw Valley State University, a regional, teaching-focused institution in Michigan’s Great Lakes Bay Region. Our programmatic development includes a recent external review conducted by the Council of Programs in Technical and Scientific Communication, and follows the cycle of assessment-to-implementation through several revolutions, tracing the evolution of usability studies as a defining local theme in our undergraduate program in Professional and Technical Writing (PTW). Annual cycles of reflection and assessment resulted in the development of a programmatic commitment to usability studies, including the development of a space to enact these practices. Further consideration of that commitment during ensuing years revealed a deepening student connection to concepts and strategies from usability studies. Although this article traces our own journey, we conclude by offering a five-part heuristic for programmatic development that readers may find useful for thinking about their own administrative priorities and practices.
Keywords. usability studies, participatory design, program administration, professional and technical writing, assessment, writing research centers
Social Justice Across The Curriculum: Research-Based Course Design
Rebecca Walton, Utah State University
Jared S. Colton, Utah State University
Rikki Wheatley-Boxx,AmeriCorps VISTA Public School Partnership
Krista Gurko, AmeriCorps VISTA Public School Partnership
Abstract. This Programmatic Showcase describes why and how Utah State University redesigned our Technical Communication and Rhetoric program to incorporate considerations of social justice across the curriculum. After describing our programmatic vision, we describe in detail the design of a pedagogical study informing our curricular redesign and then share strategies for course design and university-community partnerships. The course-design strategies include 1) explicitly framing courses around broad issues of social justice, 2) incorporating hands-on practice to connect conceptions of social justice to professional practices, and 3) facilitating opportunities for both students and clients to reflect upon these connections. The strategies for facilitating university-community relationships include 1) collaboratively designing assignments, 2) holding a kickoff meeting, and 3) creating a table summarizing assignments and timelines. We hope this article appeals to all technical communication scholars interested in social justice, though it may be most useful for program administrators interested in incorporating social justice initiatives into their respective programs.
Keywords. Social justice, program redesign, pedagogical research, service learning
Researching a New Professional Writing Major: Miami University
Heidi McKee, Miami University
Abstract. In 2011 Miami University combined an undergraduate major in Scientific and Technical Communication and an undergraduate minor in Rhetoric and Writing to create a new Professional Writing major that now enrolls approximately 200 students. This profile details how research into institutional enrollment data, student perceptions, and direct assessment of student writing contributed to the development and ongoing growth of the major. Program curriculum is shared in Appendix A.
Keywords. enrollment data, new major, professional writing, program research, survey research
Towards a Participatory Action Research Model for Extending Programmatic Assessment with Industry Advisory Boards
John M. Spartz, University of Wisconsin-Stout
Julie Watts, University of Wisconsin-Stout
Abstract. As a commentary on how professional, technical, and scientific communication programs might extend traditional approaches to programmatic assessment, this article details a conceptual model for participatory action research (PAR) that draws on a combination of data sources: an industry advisory board and reflective portfolios. We also offer “proof of concept” reflections on that framework and our own intentional advisory board engagement by describing both the process and our results from PAR at the University of Wisconsin-Stout. We further describe ways that the iterative process of PAR can and has proved instrumental in informing program development and revision that leads to student industry employment.
Keywords. advisory boards, program assessment, participatory action research, external stakeholders, industry, curriculum
Student-Centered Assessment Design in a Professional Writing Minor
Denise Tillery, University of Nevada, Las Vegas
Ed Nagelhout, University of Nevada, Las Vegas
Abstract. This article describes an approach to student-centered assessment design for a new minor in Professional Writing at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. This approach creates seamless connections among courses, breaking down course barriers to promote broader community engagement in learning networks and correlating competencies, student activities, digital assets, and program assessments. To enhance both short-term and long-term course and program assessment strategies, we take a more ethnographic approach by identifying what types of texts to analyze, what features to consider within those texts, and how those features typically evolve as students acquire, use, and eventually master the variety of skills involved. Moreover, the student-centered assessment encourages a more open and processoriented approach among students and teachers that increases learner control, learner choice, and learner independence.
Keywords. program assessment, personal learning, project development, strategies
Exploding Technical Communication: Workplace Literacy Hierarchies and Their Implications for Literacy Sponsorship. Author: Dirk Remley Baywood Publishing Company, Inc 2014, 194 pp.
Reviewed by Geoffrey Clegg, The Pennsylvania State University
Science and the Internet: Communicating Knowledge in a Digital Age, Editors: Alan G. Gross and Jonathan Buehl Afterword by Charles Bazerman Baywood Publishing Company Amityville, New York 2016. 323 pp.
Reviewed by Ryan Eichberger, University of Minnesota